Effect of Transport Cash Incentives on Routine Immunization Uptake Among Caregivers in Rural Communities. A Case Study of Gwiwa LGA, Jigawa State, Nigeria
Abstract:
Routine
immunization remains a critical public health strategy for reducing child
morbidity and mortality, yet coverage in many developing regions continues to
face significant challenges. This study examined the socio-demographic
characteristics of caregivers, the effect of cash incentives, and barriers to
attending immunization sessions. A total of 107 respondents participated in the
survey, and data were analyzed using descriptive statistics. The results
revealed that most caregivers were women within the reproductive age group,
with low levels of formal education and limited income, factors that
significantly influenced their health-seeking behavior. Despite the provision
of cash incentives, distance to health facilities (74.8%) and lack of transport
or money (45.8%) remained major barriers to attendance. However, the majority
of respondents strongly agreed (69.2%) or agreed (24.3%) that financial
incentives positively influenced their decision to attend immunization
sessions. Other barriers, such as busy schedules, health concerns, and fear of
side effects, were reported but had a less significant impact. The findings
suggest that while financial incentives play a crucial role in improving
uptake, structural and socioeconomic barriers persist in hindering access. The
study concludes that a multifaceted approach—addressing transportation,
accessibility, health education, and community awareness in addition to
financial support—is necessary to achieve sustainable improvements in
immunization coverage and child health outcomes.
References:
[1]. WHO,
2020, Routine immunization as one the most effective global public health
strategies for reducing child morbidity and mortality: Vaccines protect against
life-threatening diseases such as measles, tuberculosis, polio, and diphtheria,
saving millions of lives annually.
[2]. Oleribe,
et al., 2019, Immunization coverage in many low- and middle-income countries,
including Nigeria, Immunization in Nigeria remains inadequate due to limited
health-seeking behavior, chronic underfunding of health systems, and
socioeconomic challenges that hinder access to services.
[3]. NPC
& ICF, 2019, Survey (NDHS) revealed that only 31% of children aged 12–23
months were fully immunized in Jigawa state Nigeria.
[4]. Oleribe,
et al., 2017, Immunization challenges in Nigeria Rural communities. Rural
communities in Nigeria including those in Jigawa State, face additional
challenges such as long distances to health facilities, poor road conditions,
and financial constraints that limit access to vaccination services.
[5]. Ozawa,
et al., 2012, Effect of financial incentives on health seeking behavior in
Northern Nigeria: Evidence from behavioral economics suggests that even small
financial incentives can significantly influence health-seeking behavior,
especially among low-income households.
[6]. Fagbamigbe
& Kandala, 2021, Conditional and unconditional cash transfers can improve
uptake of maternal and child health services, including antenatal care,
facility-based delivery, and immunization.
[7]. Yakubu,
et al., 2019, Gwiwa Local Government Area (LGA) of Jigawa State is a
predominantly rural region where socioeconomic constraints and limited
infrastructure pose challenges to healthcare delivery and utilization.
[8]. WHO
& UNICEF, 2019, Broader equity-driven efforts aimed at ensuring that no
child is left behind due to financial or geographic barriers to immunization.
[9]. WHO
& Gavi, 2020, Routine immunization remains one of the most cost-effective
public health interventions globally, helping to prevent childhood morbidity
and mortality from vaccine-preventable diseases.
[10]. NPC
& ICF, 2019, UNICEF, 2021, National health surveys consistently show that
routine immunization coverage often falls below recommended levels, exposing
children under two to preventable health risks.
[11]. Lakew,
et al., 2015, Fagbamigbe & Kandala, 2021, transportation costs pose a
significant obstacle, as many caregivers in rural communities cannot afford
travel to distant health facilities.
[12]. Odusanya, et al., 2008, Adedokun, et al., 2017, Yakubu, et al., 2019, In
Jigawa State Nigeria, low immunization uptake has been linked to several
barriers, including poor access to health facilities, limited awareness among
caregivers, cultural beliefs, and financial constraints.
[13]. UNICEF,
2021, NPC & ICF, 2019, MICS, 2021, Nigeria national surveys and zero-dose
landscape analyses show lower coverage in many northern states (including the
North-West) and highlight distance, transport cost, and socioeconomic
constraints as major demand-side barriers
[14]. Barham, T., & Maluccio, J. A., 2009, Eradicating diseases: The effect
of conditional cash transfers on vaccination coverage in rural Nicaragua. Journal
of Health Economics, 28(3), 611–621.
[15]. Ozawa,
et al., 2012, Systematic and scoping reviews from LMICs, over the past decade
conclude that monetary incentives can raise vaccine uptake, though effect sizes
vary based on context, transfer size, and program design.
[16]. NPC
& ICF, 2019, UNICEF, 2021, Oleribe, et al., 2017, Nigeria national surveys,
The NDHS and MICS show lower coverage in many northern states, including the
North-West, and highlight distance, transport cost, and socioeconomic
constraints as major demand-side barriers.
[17].
Adepoju, P., 2021, Nigeria’s
immunization coverage: Progress, challenges, and future directions. The
Lancet Global Health, 9(3), e247–e248. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2214-109X(21)00043-6
[18]. Barham & Maluccio, 2009, Ozawa et al., 2012, Earlier
economic and public health evidence also demonstrates that conditional cash
transfers improve vaccination outcomes in similar low-resource contexts.
[19].
Adedokun, S. T., & Yaya, S., 2020,
Correlates of childhood immunization in Nigeria: Evidence from the Demographic
and Health Survey. BMC Public Health, 20(1), 1–10.
[20]. Ajzen,
1991, The Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB), explains that human behavior is
influenced by three main factors: attitudes toward the behavior, subjective
norms, and perceived behavioral control.
[21]. Rosenstock,
et al., 1988, The health belief model (HBM), posits that individuals’
willingness to act depends on their perceived susceptibility to illness,
perceived severity of the illness, perceived benefits of taking action, and
perceived barriers to action.
[22]. Skinner,
1953, The Incentive Theory of Motivation (ITM) suggests that human behavior is
often driven by external rewards or incentives.
[23]. Yakubu, et al., 2019, Oleribe, et al., 2017, Caregivers
utilizing immunization services in northern Nigeria. Studies in northern
Nigeria have shown that, caregivers utilizing immunization services are
predominantly married women.
[24]. NPC
& ICF, 2019, Nigeria national surveys, demonstrating that caregivers of
young children in northern Nigeria are predominantly women aged 25–39 years.
[25]. uptake
Odusanya et al., 2008, Adedokun & Yaya, 2020, Literacy level among gender
in Northern Nigeria. Northern Nigeria has lower female educational attainment,
a factor strongly associated with reduced health-seeking behavior and
suboptimal immunization.
[26]. Fagbamigbe & Kandala, 2021, Occupational pattern among caregivers in rural Northern Nigeria. Occupational patterns have been observed in rural immunization studies, where most caregivers are unemployed or engaged in low-income work.
