A Meaningful Psychometric Test or a Deceptive Ouija Board? a Critical Analytical Review of the Rorschach Inkblot Test
Abstract:
Controversy has surrounded the
Rorschach throughout most of its history, not because it is worthless, but
because it has so often been used for the wrong purposes. Psychlit, PEP,
PubMed, Google scholar, CAB Abstracts and article references were searched to
identify critical commentaries and published globally in English between 1921 and
2012. Findings of the review suggest that the virtues of the Rorschach are
modest but genuine.
References:
[1.] Acklin M. W. & Oliveira-Berry J. (1996). Return to
the source: Rorschach's Psychodiagnostics. Journal of Personality Assessment
67: 427–433.
[2.] Alexander, M. (2001). Lee Cronbach, pioneer in
educational psychology dead at 85. Stanford Report (Stanford University School
of Education). Accessed 28 December 2011 from
http://ed.stanford.edu/suse/news¬bureau/displayRecord.php?tablename=press&id=12
[3.] Alfred, R. (2009). April 2, 1922: Rorschach Dies,
Leaving a Blot on His Name at wired.com Accessed on 28 December 2011 at
http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2009/04/dayintech_0402 a.
disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC.
[4.] Aronow, E. & Reznikoff, M. (1976). Rorschach
content interpretation. New York: Grune & Stratton. p. 7.
[5.] Bornstein, R. F. (1996). Construct validity of the
Rorschach Oral Dependency Scale: 1967– 1995. Psychological Assessment, 8,
200–205.
[6.] Bornstein, R. F., Hilsenroth, M. J. & Padawer, J.
R. (2000). Interpersonal dependency and personality pathology: Variations in
Rorschach Oral Dependency scores across Axis II disorders. Journal of Personality
Assessment, 75, 478–491.
[7.] Buros, O.K. (1975). Personality tests and reviews:
including an index to the mental measurements yearbooks, Volume 1. Gryphon
Press.
[8.] Butcher J.A. (1992). Introduction to the special
section on assessment in psychological treatment: a necessary step for
effective intervention. Psychological Assessment, 9, 331-333.
[9.] Chapman, L.J. &Chapman, J. (1982). Test results
are what you think they are. In Kahneman, D, Slovic, P. & Tversky, A.
Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge
University Press. pp. 238–248.
[10.] Coleman, M. J., Levy, D. L, Lenzenweger, M. F. &
Holzman, P. S. (1996). Thought disorder, perceptual aberrations, and
schizotypy. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 105, 469– 473.
[11.] Cronbach, L. J. (1970). Essentials of psychological
testing (3rd ed.). New York: Harper & Row. Dana, R.H. (1999). Handbook of
Cross-Cultural and Multicultural Personality Assessment (Personality and
Clinical Psychology Series).
[12.] Dawes, M.R. (1991). Giving up Cherished Ideas: The
Rorschach Ink Blot Test. Institute for Psychological Therapies Journal 3, 4.
Accessed 30 December 2011 from
http://www.ipt-forensics.com/journal/volume3/j3_4_5.htm
[13.] Drenth, P.J.D. (2003). Growing Anti-intellectualism in
Europe: A Menace to Science. Annual Report 2003. ALLEA (All European
Academies). Accessed 4 January 2012 from
http://www.allea.org/Pages/ALL/4/881.pdf#page=61 Volume 1. Hoboken, NJ: John
Wiley & Sons.
[14.] Exner, J. E. (2003). The Rorschach: A comprehensive
system. Basic foundations and principles of interpretation (4th ed.). New York:
Wiley.
[15.] Frank, G. (1990). Research on the clinical usefulness
of the Rorschach: 1. The diagnosis of schizophrenia. Perceptual and Motor
Skills, 71, 573–578.
[16.] Garb, H.N. (1999). Call for a moratorium on the use of
the Rorschach Inkblot Test in clinical and forensic settings. Assessment, 6,4:
313–8.
[17.] Garb, H.N., Wood, J.M., Lilienfeld, S.O. &
Nezworski, M.T. (2005). Roots of the Rorschach controversy. Clinical
Psychological Review, 25 (1): 97–118.
[18.] Garb, H. N., Wood, J. M., Nezworski, M. T., Grove, W.
M. & Stejskal, W. J.( 2001). Toward a resolution of the Rorschach
controversy. Psychological Assessment, 13, 433–448.
[19.] Gacono, C. B. & Evans F.B. (2007). The Handbook of
Forensic Rorschach Assessment. New York: Routledge
[20.] Gacono, C. B., & Meloy, J. R. (1994). The
Rorschach assessment of aggressive and psychopathic personalities. Hillsdale,
NJ: Erlbaum.
[21.] Goldfried, M. R., Stricker, G. & Weiner, I. B.
(1971). Rorschach handbook of clinical and research applications. Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
[22.] Goldman, H.H. (2000). Review of General Psychiatry.
Maryland: McGraw-Hill.
[23.] Goldstein, G & Hersen, M( eds). (2000). Handbook
of psychological assessment. Amsterdam: Pergamon Press. p. 437.
[24.] Greaves, A. R. (2000). A validation of Wagner’s
Rorschach autism classification system. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
Forest Institute of Professional Psychology.
[25.] Groth-Marnat, G. (2003). Handbook of Psychological
Assessment. Canada: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
[26.] Hardman , D. (2009). Judgement and Decision making:
Psychological perspectives. West Sussex: BPS Blackwell.
[27.] Hauser, R. J. (1963). The validity of the formal and
linguistic aspects of the Rorschach in predicting intelligence. (Doctoral
dissertation, New York University, 1962). Dissertation Abstracts International,
24, 833.
[28.] Johnston, M. H. & Holzman, P. S. (1979). Assessing
schizophrenic thinking. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
[29.] .Jorgensen, K., Andersen, T. J. & Dam, H. (2000).
The diagnostic efficiency of the Rorschach depression index and the
schizophrenia index: A review. Assessment, 7, 259–280.
[30.] Khadivi, A., Wetzler, S. & Wilson, A. (1997).
Manic indexes on the Rorschach. Journal of Personality Assessment, 69, 365–375.
Klopfer, B. (1940). Personality aspects revealed by the Rorschach method.
Rorschach Research Exchange, 4, 26–29.
[31.] Knight, R. A. & Silverstein, S. M. (1998). The
role of cognitive psychology in guiding research on cognitive deficits in
schizophrenia: A process-oriented approach. In M. F. Lenzenweger & R. H.
Dworkin (Eds.), Origins and development of schizophrenia. Advances in
experimental psychopathology (pp. 247–295).
[32.] Kubiszyn, T. W., Meyer, G. J., Finn, S. E.& Eyde,
L. D. (2000). Empirical support for psychological assessment in clinical health
care settings. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 31, 119–130.
[33.] Lang, M. (1989). Psicologia clinica. Milano: F.
Angeli. ( "Nonostante il Sistema Comprensivo di J.E. Exner rappresenti ai
nostri giorni il Metodo Rorschach più diffuso a livello mondiale, in Italia è
ancora non molto utilizzato. Although J. E. Exner's Comprehensive Systems
nowadays represents the most widely adopted method worldwide, it is not yet
very widespread in Italy.”).
[34.] Lilienfeld, S.O., Wood,J.M. & Garb, H.N. (2001).
What's wrong with this picture? Scientific American.
[35.] Lowrey, L.G. (1946). American journal of
orthopsychiatry. American Orthopsychiatric Association, 16, p. 732.
[36.] Meyer, G. J. (1992). The Rorschach’s factor structure:
A contemporary investigation and historical review. Journal of Personality
Assessment, 59, 117–136.
[37.] Meyer, G. J. (2001). Evidence to correct
misperceptions about Rorschach norms. Clinical Psychology: Science and
Practice, 8, 389–396.
[38.] Meyer, G. J., & Handler, L. (1997). The ability of
the Rorschach to predict subsequent outcome: A meta-analysis of the Rorschach
Prognostic Rating Scale. Journal of Personality Assessment, 69, 1–38.
[39.] Meyer, G. J., Hilsenroth, M. J., Baxter, D., Exner, J.
E., Fowler, J. C., Piers, C. C. & Resnick J. (2002). An examination of
interrater reliability for scoring the Rorschach comprehensive system in eight
data sets. Journal of Personality Assessment, 78 (2): 219–274.
[40.] Nisbett, R. E. & Ross, L. (1980). Human inference:
Strategies and shortcomings of social judgment. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall. Pichot, P. (1984). Centenary of the birth of Hermann Rorschach.
(Rosenzweig, S. & Schriber, E. Trans.). Journal of Personality Assessment
48: 591–596.
[41.] Radford, B. (2009). Rorschach Test: Discredited But
Still Controversial. Accessed on 26 December 2011 from
http://www.livescience.com/9695-rorschach-test-discredited-controversial.html
[42.] Rapaport, D., Gill, M. & Schafer, R. (1946).
Diagnostic psychological testing. Vol. II. Chicago: Year Book Publishers.
[43.] Raynor, P. & McIvor, G. (2008). Developments in
Social Work Offenders (Research Highlights in Social Work). London: Jessica
Kingsley Publishers. p. 138.
[44.] Reber, A.S. (1985). Penguin Dictionary of Psychology.
Penguin Books.
[45.] Romesh.V. (2003). Textbook Of Statistics, Psychology
& Education. Anmol Publications.
[46.] Rorschach, H. (1927). Rorschach Test –
Psychodiagnostic Plates. Hogrefe.
[47.] Routledge Davis, H. S. (1961). Judgments of
intellectual level from various features of the Rorschach including vocabulary.
Journal of Projective Techniques, 25, 155–157.